Oct 18, 2017 | Featured in: Watching Backyard Birds, October 2016

Ask Birdsquatch: Feeder Hogs

A European starling greedily eyes the offerings at a suet feeder.
Share:

Dear Birdsquatch:

It seems like I spend a blue million dollars on birdseed every month. I love the woodpeckers and have a nice variety of them at the feeder—even an occasional red-headed—but the blackbirds and house sparrows are eating me out of house and home. Is there something I can do to attract only woodpeckers and, you know, the sweet little birds like chickadees and cardinals, but not starlings or grackles or house sparrows? The only seed mix I use contains sunflower seeds and nuts—no millet or corn or milo. I offer suet, too. The woodpeckers are bringing their fledglings to it! A friend suggested I stop feeding altogether for a few weeks, but that seems so harsh. I want birds at my bird feeder... well, some birds. I hope you can help me, Birdsquatch!

—DONNA F., WINCHESTER, VIRGINIA

Dear Donna,

Many of your fellow bird lovers feel the same way about these feathered vacuum cleaners visiting their feeders. I was going to quote The Outlaw Josey Wales in my answer: "When things look bad and it looks like you're not gonna make it, that's when you get mean, I mean plumb mad-dog mean!"

But that seems a little harsh.

A better solution is to outsmart them. House sparrows will eat anything, but they don't really like black-oil sunflower seed. So don't offer any cracked corn or mixed seed on the ground. This will also discourage the grackles. Use only hanging feeders, and limit ground feeding.

For the starlings, make them work really hard for their food. Offer suet only in feeders with access on the bottom surface. Woodpeckers can cling to these types of feeders, but starlings, grackles, and house sparrows have a hard time clinging long enough to eat much at all.

Blackbird flocks—including starlings—can sometimes descend on a feeder and dominate it for a few days at a time, but they normally move on soon thereafter. House sparrows are year-round residents, so you'll have to keep up your anti-sparrow efforts throughout the year.

You're just lucky that you're not trying to keep sasquatches off your feeders! We're relentless—especially if there's blueberry pie involved.



About Birdsquatch

Birdsquatch is WBB's tall, hairy, and slightly stinky columnist. He is a bigfoot who has watched birds all his life. His home range is unknown.

What do you think? Tell us!

comments powered by Disqus

New On This Site

The Latest Comments

  • #18 in the Gallery is misidentified as a Tree Sparrow, instead of Tree Swallow.
    by Ron, Mon, 23 Apr 2018
  • yep i do the microwave too....they don't break down in our compost so the birds get them!
    by ecumam2, Wed, 18 Apr 2018
  • As you probably know, sunflower seed hulls have a bio-chemical in them, (allelopathic), which keeps any other seeds from sprouting, in the same area. I have used this fact, to a purpose. With a large build up, each year (& yes, it is a bare spot!), I rake up the "bounty" & spread them on areas of bulbs & perennials to keep the annual weeds down. It's also helpful near blue squill bulbs, which drop seeds through the fence that divides a perennial garden, from the lawn , where they are welcome to naturalize. The garden can be over run with them, so sunflower hulls can keep the sprouting down.
    by Plntlady, Tue, 17 Apr 2018
  • I do this in a small garden, near our road, where winter road sand can build up & bury the small, low-growing plants that live there. In spring I just pick up the burlap & shake it back onto the road, before the road crew comes by with the street sweeper, in spring.
    by Plntlady, Tue, 17 Apr 2018
  • Thanks, now I can not worry so much. It's April 17, here in NE Vt. & is snowing big snowflakes. Yesterday we have scary, high winds & it's refusing to be spring. A phoebe, which was so puffed up I didn't recognize it, except for it's insectivore beak, showed up near the feeders, on my porch. It flew to a low branch, in a sugar maple & has been huddled there for quite a while. I was sure it was a phoebe when I observed it's tail bobbing, when first landing. I assume it is now being still, trying to reserve body heat. I have a frozen, cut pomegranate, hanging from the porch & we have an ample supply of sumac berries & other native fruiting plants, so hopefully it will find what it needs.... Also spotted a brown creeper, on the trunk of one of our big, old sugar maples, this morning.
    by Plntlady, Tue, 17 Apr 2018